Toggenburg Mountain, NY, Set to Reopen after Four-Year Battle in Court

Kien Warren | | Post Tag for Industry NewsIndustry News
Toggenburg Mountain, NY on January 26th, 2015. photo: toggenburg
Toggenburg Mountain, NY, on January 26, 2015. | Photo: Toggenburg Mountain

Toggenburg was once a staple of Central New York skiing. The resort, which opened in 1953, operated continuously for nearly 70 years before being shut down, seemingly permanently, in 2021. At its peak, Toggenburg was home to five lifts accessing 21 trails and about 700 vertical feet of skiing, open day and night.

That all changed when the resort was purchased by a company called Intermountain Management in August 2021. It bought Toggenburg for $2.25 million from John and Christine Meier, who had been operating Toggenburg for the past several years, and immediately closed the ski area ahead of the ensuing winter season.

At the time, Intermountain stated that it closed the resort due to an oversaturation of the local ski market, given that there were three ski areas within a 12-mile radius. It also cited pandemic-era labor shortages and a declining local population as reasons why continuing to operate Toggenburg would have proven unsustainable.

The validity of these claims, however, remained in question, especially given the prior years’ success seen at Toggenburg. The resort had, in fact, been profitable in the years leading up to its closure, selling about 3,500 season passes per year and seeing around 100,000 annual skier visits. This led locals and government officials alike to question whether ulterior motives had led Intermountain to close the successful Syracuse area mountain.

Toggenburg, New York, Closed Ski Area
Skiers ride a chairlift at the now-closed Toggenburg Mountain, NY. | Photo: Michael Greenlar/Syracuse.com

Many suspected that Intermountain Management had acquired Toggenburg with the predetermined goal of shutting it down. This would be to the company’s benefit, as it also owns the two other main ski areas in the Syracuse area: Labrador Mountain and Song Mountain Resort. The closure of Toggenburg meant a near monopoly on local skiing for Intermountain Management, giving it full control of the market and even allowing it to artificially inflate prices at the remaining ski areas, given the lack of local competition.

In October 2022, New York Attorney General Letitia James argued exactly that, suing Intermountain Management on antitrust grounds. She alleged that the company had bought and shut down its only local competitor, ridding the area of competition and leading to higher prices and more crowded slopes for Syracuse skiers. Additionally, the attorney general stated that Intermountain Management had added deed restrictions ensuring Toggenburg could never be redeveloped as a ski area, while paying the previous owners to sign a five-year agreement not to compete within a 30-mile radius.

Essentially, James argued that Intermountain Management had paid a premium to eliminate competition from the area, while not even operating the resort it had acquired, as a way to avoid operational expenses. This not only gave regional skiers fewer options but ensured the resorts that remained would provide a worse yet more expensive experience.

Toggenburg, New York, Syracuse
Banner in nearby Fabius, NY, calls for the reopening of Toggenburg. | Photo: Rick Moriarty/syracuse.com

On February 24, 2025, well over two years after the lawsuit was filed, Justice Robert E. Antonacci II ruled in favor of the attorney general, finding that the 2021 acquisition of Toggenburg hurt the skier experience, dramatically diminished local competition, and was, in fact, illegal. Finally, on October 16, 2026, after roughly four years in court, a settlement was reached by all parties involved, which will bring skiing back to the slopes of Toggenburg in the near future.

The settlement mandated that Intermountain Management sell the resort to Douglas Wheeler, a local businessman whose stated mission is to bring skiing back to the mountain, while mandating the company pay an additional $30,000 to the state of New York. Wheeler’s goal is to “return (Toggenburg) to its former glory while modernizing the technology and adding new attractions.” While he does not have any ski industry experience, Wheeler does have deep ties to the mountain, as it was his great-grandfather who owned the land Toggenburg now sits on before selling it to the family that opened the ski area in 1953.

It’s important to note that the New York ski hill won’t be back up and running overnight. Getting the resort back to operational status will be a huge undertaking, according to Wheeler himself, and Toggenburg isn’t expected to reopen until the 2027-28 season. Nonetheless, in the somewhat near future, Toggenburg will be back, giving Central New York skiers more options, potentially lower prices and, overall, better winters.


Related Articles

Got an opinion? Let us know...